I was packing up to head to church Sunday morning, and I had to remember to grab my mics and a few mic clips. For those that serve in rougher areas, you might have had to do this to combat "walking off". But we always have what we need, and are able to work around 4-5 different services with tons of nationalities represented.
I think back to my touring days, and my friends that serve as Technical Directors at large churches and how our conversations usually lead to the newest A/V gear designed for churches. Even when I led the Worship Design Team at Asbury we had to keep up with the variety of ways people wanted to show clips or use a slide presentation. With the demise of live music in smaller venues, and the rise of the Mega-Styled church, the audio-visual world loves churches. We bring in BIG money and the industry keeps technology updates aggressive and frequent.
Folks, we are in an Arms Race
We have to have the latest version of Propresentor, cause that is what they used at Catalyst. If we want the Easter program to go well, we have to get 5 new intellabeams and the church down the street just got in ear monitors, so we need to find 5 grand in the budget for that.
For musicians in church, we have the same stress. If you play electric guitar, you have to have a Timmy overdrive and a delay with tap tempo dotted 8th notes....cause that is what the guys from HillSong use. Worship leaders have you ever felt the need to have a fancier guitar than what is currently getting the job done, because the "big guys" aren't even using Taylor anymore? Drummers, maybe your quality Pearl, Tama or even DW kit isn't cutting it, because the newer custom drum market has been baptized and there are "christian" companies that make killer trap sets. As a guitar player, I love gear, but I have to always remind myself that it doesn't matter in the scheme of things.
Does your Pastor feel the need to get an iPad for his sermon notes? Those things are handy, I would love one (EDIT, I have had 2 by now)...but I wonder how many TD's have bought a few iPads just out of peer pressure. Having an iPhone is possibly more important, because it is necessary to use apps like YouVersion to keep your teaching and discipleship ministries up to date with what the church plant down the street does. Think how we often force older pastors (and I don't mean senior citizens. Those in their late 40's early 50's.) to use social media because that is what our church needs to do, but it is hard because they never really understood email.
Keeping up is the elephant in the room, especially with smaller churches or new congregations. We have convinced ourselves that in order to keep people in the seats we have to stay on top of trends and equipment and have let it slip in as gospel message. Performative excellence has become a subset of the Great Commission.
The place where this simply doesn't work is that God is timeless; Christ is the same always (Heb 13:8). The gospel is without innovation, it doesn't change. The way that we interact within our culture changes, and it is important to have the ability to resonate within changing cultures. But we can't allow that to invade our worship. We live within a consuming, entertainment oriented and material culture. That must be kept in mind when we design and lead worship, but it should not be the driving vehicle or motivation. Creative for the sake of creative isn't ok. I have to tell myself this very often, because I find many new things to be fascinating and really awesome.
Songwriters have varying definitions of what makes up a good song. Paul McCartney and John Lennon supposedly had a rule that if a song did not grab them at its simplest version, with one person and one instrument, there was no way it could be made better with the full extent of arrangement and production.
If Christian worship depends on the dog and pony show...we have to start thinking "is this really Christian worship?" Production has always been a part of worship, the early church was highly experiential, but it was always to tell the story of God and draw the person deeper and deeper into Christ. We can argue this for our current corporate worship system, but it is not necessary to rival the cold war in our acquisition habits. To think we need 92 channels of aux sends for God to reveal himself shows a gaping whole in our theology.
I am consistently for innovation (and this post is as much a confession as it is anything else), but not at the expense of how we view the operative qualities of the relationship between God and His Church.
The elements around us are part of the story, but they are not necessary for the relationship.
Recent Comments